Tag Archives: George Eliot Middlemarch

the head versus the heart

 

Mr Casaubon and Dorthea’s letters

 

The Word document posted here (above) is an excerpt from Chapter V of George Eliot’s Middlemarch, in which there is an exchange of letters between Rev, Edward Casaubon and Dorothea Brooke. Mr. Casaubon has decided to propose to Dorothea.

Mr. Casaubon’s letter is a great example of over intellectualizing the emotions (such as I myself used to do sometimes in my youth; reading about the life of distant others can help one to better understand oneself), and of verbosity. So that would could be said plainly becomes encumbered in exposition.

Note how Dorothea does just the opposite in her response, saying what needs to be said in just three sentences.

 

— posted by Roger W. Smith

   June 2024

he had his half-century before him

 

“he had his half-century before him instead of behind him”

Thus notes George Eliot in her great novel Middlemarch, in reference to one her characters, Lydgate, a young doctor.

It made me think of Isaiah, a man in his twenties who was briefly working as a waiter at a pub I frequent.

We had some good talks. He was attending Howard University, had dropped out for no apparent reason, was trying to do different things, was personable, friendly; articulate; had a keen mind, which was apparent, and intellectual ability. He was trying to orient himself; was sort of drifting; though was not lost; had moved back briefly with family in Harlem.

He was contemplating doing something interesting, getting into some field for talented people — I can’t recall what it was.

We had earnest conversations. I told him: Your whole life, future, possibilities, are ahead of you. He was listening, but I am not sure it totally sunk in.

I thought about this when reading George Eliot at the same pub today.

My therapist, Dr. Colp, said the exact same thing (as I said to Isaiah) to me once, more than forty years ago.

I realized this, sort of, then. One might say, half realized.

How quickly life passes.

 

— posted by Roger W. Smith

   May 26, 2O24

PS – I told Isaiah that Isaiah was one of the Old Testament prophets we studied in a course I took at Brandeis University. He already knew about him.