James T. Farell, ‘Twain’s Huckleberry Finn’ – NYTBR 12-12-1943
Posted here (PDF above) is an article by James T. Farrell:
“Twain’s ‘Huckleberry Finn’ and the Era He Lived In”
The New York Times Book Review
December 12, 1943
I have been an admirer of Farrell ever since I read Studs Lonigan. (I can thank my wife for calling my attention to it.) Farrell’s novel of boyhood recalls Twain and gave him insight into Huckleberry Finn.
There is an unforgettable passage in Chapter XXXI of Twain’s Adventures of Huckleberry Finn, in which Tom wrestles with his scruples, his conscience. He knows he should do “the right thing” and turn Jim, the runaway slave, in, but he just can’t bring himself to do it:
“[I] got to thinking over our trip down the river; and I see Jim before me all the time: in the day and in the night-time, sometimes moonlight, sometimes storms, and we a-floating along, talking and singing and laughing. But somehow I couldn’t seem to strike no places to harden me against him, but only the other kind. I’d see him standing my watch on top of his’n, ‘stead of calling me, so I could go on sleeping; and see him how glad he was when I come back out of the fog; and when I come to him again in the swamp, up there where the feud was; and such-like times; and would always call me honey, and pet me and do everything he could think of for me, and how good he always was; and at last I struck the time I saved him by telling the men we had small-pox aboard, and he was so grateful, and said I was the best friend old Jim ever had in the world, and the only one he’s got now. …
I can’t resist saying: what a great passage!
— posted by Roger W. Smith
August 2023
La huictiesme nous arriuasmes aux trois Riuieres, le seiour y est fort agréable, la terre sablonneuse, la pesche en son temps tres-abõdante. Vn Sauuage rapportera quelquefois dans son Canot douze ou quinze Esturgeons, dont le moindre sera par fois de la hauteur d’vn homme. Il y a quantité d’autres poissons tres-excellens. Les Français ont nõmé ce lieu les trois Riuieres, pource qu’il sort des terres vn assez beau fleuue, qui se vient dégorger dans la grande Riuiere de sainct Laurens par trois principales emboucheures, causées par plusieurs petites Isles, qui se rencontrent à l’entrée de ce fleuue, nommé des Sauuages Metaberoutin. Ie décrirois volontiers la beauté de ce lieu, mais ie crains d’estre long; Tout le pays entre Kebec & ceste nouuelle Habitation, que nous appellerõs la Residence de la Conception, m’a semblé fort agreable, il est entrecoupé de ruisseaux & de fleuues, qui se déchargent d’espaces en espaces dans le Roy des fleuues, c’est à dire, dans la grande riuiere de S. Laurens, qui a bien encore en ce lieu là quelque deux à trois mille pas de large quoy qu’il soit à trente lieuës au dessus de Kebec.
On the eighth, we arrived at the three Rivers. We found living there very agreeable; the ground is sandy, the fish very abundant in its season. A Savage will sometimes bring in his Canoe twelve or fifteen Sturgeon, the smallest of which is occasionally as long as the height of a man; besides these, there are also a number of other very good fish. The French have named this place the three Rivers, because there emerges here a very beautiful river which flows into the great River saint Lawrence through three principal mouths, caused by several little Islands which are found at the entrance of this river, which the Savages call Metaberoutin. I would like to describe the beauty of this place, but I am afraid of being tedious. The whole country between Kebec and this new Settlement, which we will call the Residence of the Conception, seems to me very pleasant; it is intersected by brooks and streams, which empty at short distances from each other into the King of rivers, that is, into the great river St. Lawrence, which is, even at this place, fully two or three thousand paces wide, although it is thirty leagues above Quebec.
— Le Jeune’s relation, The Jesuit Relations and Allied Documents, Volume 8: Quebec, Hurons, Cape Breton, 1634-1636 (1897)
*****************************************************
Few passages of history are more striking than those which record the efforts of the earlier French Jesuits to convert the Indians. Full as they are of dramatic and philosophic interest, bearing strongly on the political destinies of America, and closely involved with the history of its native population, it is wonderful that they have been left so long in obscurity. While the infant colonies of England still clung feebly to the shores of the Atlantic, events deeply ominous to their future were in progress, unknown to them, in the very heart of the continent. It will be seen, in the sequel of this volume, that civil and religious liberty found strange allies in this Western World.
The sources of information concerning the early Jesuits of New France are very copious. During a period of forty years, the Superior of the Mission vi sent, every summer, long and detailed reports, embodying or accompanied by the reports of his subordinates, to the Provincial of the Order at Paris, where they were annually published, in duodecimo volumes, forming the remarkable series known as the Jesuit Relations. Though the productions of men of scholastic training, they are simple and often crude in style, as might be expected of narratives hastily written in Indian lodges or rude mission-houses in the forest, amid annoyances and interruptions of all kinds. In respect to the value of their contents, they are exceedingly unequal. Modest records of marvellous adventures and sacrifices, and vivid pictures of forest-life, alternate with prolix and monotonous details of the conversion of individual savages, and the praiseworthy deportment of some exemplary neophyte. With regard to the condition and character of the primitive inhabitants of North America, it is impossible to exaggerate their value as an authority. I should add, that the closest examination has left me no doubt that these missionaries wrote in perfect good faith, and that the Relations hold a high place as authentic and trustworthy historical documents. They are very scarce, and no complete collection of them exists in America. …
— Francis Parkman, Preface; The Jesuits in North America in the Seventeenth Century (Boston: Little, Brown, And Company. 1867)
*****************************************************
commentary by Roger W. Smith
The Jesuit Relations, Relations des Jésuites de la Nouvelle-France, were chronicles of the Jesuit missions in New France written by Jesuit missionaries in the seventeenth century. The reports were written annually beginning in 1632 and ending in 1673. They were originally written in French, Latin, and Italian.
Comprising reports to their superiors in France, the Relations concerned the missionaries’ interactions with various North American tribes and their activities for the purpose of converting the indigenous peoples.
The missionaries made major efforts to study and understand indigenous cultures and to learn native languages.
The Relations included descriptions of the natural landscape and climactic and geographical conditions not encountered in France; also of warfare and martyrdom. An example of the former is Paul Le Jeune’s description of a journey through the woods with a band of Montagnais people, in which he describes physical hardships of carrying a great deal of belongings in the cold, with little food. The latter includes narratives of Jesuit missionaries being killed or maimed. For example: the missionaries Isaac Jogues, who died after being captured by the Mohawks, and Jean de Brébeuf. Much attention is devoted to Indians who became converts to Catholicism.
Beginning in 1896, Reuben Gold Thwaites, secretary of the Wisconsin Historical Society, led a project to translate into English, unify, and cross-reference the original Relations. Thwaites and his associates compiled 73 volumes. The Thwaites edition is posted here.
By the Jesuit missionaries, the natives were called sauvages (savages). The designation in many respect seems apt.
The indigenous (Indian) peoples had a rich vocabulary for concrete things, but no words for or conception of (concepts designating) abstract ideas or terms. Most notable (they always took captives, when possible, alive) was their ferocity and cruelty in torturing their captives.
There are passages of beauty in these relations, in which the natural landscape – woods, lakes, and streams; mountain and sky, snow and ice — are described. There is much of interest about native customs and practices. There are moving stories of religiosity, hardship, and courage.
But the descriptions of torture and martyrdom are such that one cannot bear to read them.
I became acquainted with the Jesuit Relations from reading, in its entirety, Francis Parkman’s monumental work France and England in North America. Parkman’s The Jesuits in North America in the Seventeenth Century (1867) comprises the second and third of eight volumes.
— posted by Roger W. Smith
July 2023
*****************************************************
individual volumes (PDF)
Vol. I
ACADIA: 1610-1613
Vol. II
ACADIA: 1612-1614
Vol. III
ACADIA: 1611-1616
Vol. IV
ACADIA AND QUEBEC: 1616-1629
Vol. V
QUEBEC: 1632-1633
Vol. V, pp. 168-169 (defective in above PDF)
Vol. VI
QUEBEC: 1633-1634
Vol. VII
QUEBEC, HURONS, CAPE BRETON: 1634-1635
Vol. VIII
QUEBEC, HURONS, CAPE BRETON 1634-1636
Vol. IX
QUEBEC: 1636
Vol. X
HURONS: 1636
Vol. XI
HURONS AND QUEBEC: 1636-1637
Vol. XII
QUEBEC: 1637
Vol. XIII
HURONS : 1637
Vol. XIV
HURONS AND QUEBEC: 1637-1638
Vol. XV
HURONS AND QUEBEC: 1638-1639
Vol. XVI
QUEBEC AND HURONS: 1639
Vol. XVII
HURONS AND THREE RIVERS: 1639- 1640
Vol. XVIII
HURONS AND QUEBEC: 1640
Vol. XIX
QUEBEC AND HURONS: 1640
Vol. XX
HURONS AND QUEBEC: 1640- 1641
Vol. XXI
QUEBEC AND HURONS: 1641-1642
Vol. XXII
QUEBEC AND HURONS: 1642
Vol. XXIII
HURONS, QUEBEC, IROQUOIS: 1642- 1643
Vol. XXIV
LOWER CANADA AND IROQUOIS: 1642- 1643
Vol. XXV
IROQUOIS, HURONS, QUEBEC: 1642-1644
Vol. XXVI
LOWER CANADA, HURONS: 1642- 1644
Vol XXVII
HURONS LOWER CANADA: 1642 1645
Vol XXVII (facing pages)
Vol. XXVIII (page 113 missing)
HURONS, IROQUOIS, LOWER CANADA: 1645- 1646
28 jesuits28jesuuoft PAGE 113 MISING
Vol. XXVIII, pp. 113-115
Vol. XXIX
IROQUOIS, LOWER CANADA, HURONS: 1646
Vol. XXX
HURONS, LOWER CANADA: 1646-1647
Vol. XXXI
IROQUOIS, LOWER CANADA, ABENAKIS: 1647
Vol. XXXII
HURONS, LOWER CANADA: 1647-1648
Vol. XXXIII
LOWER CANADA, ALGONKINS, HURONS: 1648-1649
Vol. XXXIV
LOWER CANADA, HURONS: 1649
Vol. XXXV
HURONS, LOWER CANADA, ALGONKINS: 1650
Vol. XXXVI
LOWER CANADA, ABENAKIS, 1650-1651
Vol. XXXVII
LOWER CANADA, ABENAKIS: 165 I – 1652
Vol. XXXVIII
ABENAKIS, LOWER CANADA, HURONS: 1652-1653
Vol. XXXIX
HURONS: 1653
Vol. XL
HURONS, LOWER CANADA, IROQUOIS: 1653
Vol. XLI
LOWER CANADA, IROQUOIS: 1654- 1656
Vol. XLII
LOWER CANADA, IROQUOIS: 1632- 1657
Vol. XLIII
LOWER CANADA, IROQUOIS: 1656- 1657
Vol. XLIV
IROQUOIS, LOWER CANADA: 1656- 1658
Vol. XLV
LOWER CANADA, ACADIA, IROQUOIS, OTTAWAS: 1659- 1660
Vol XLVI
LOWER CANADA, ACADIA, IROQUOIS, OTTAWAS: 1659- 1661
Vol. XLVII
IROQUOIS, LOWER CANADA: 1661 – 1663
Vol. XLVIII
LOWER CANADA, OTTAWAS: 1662 – 1664
Vol. XLIX
LOWER CANADA, IROQUOIS: 1663- 1665
Vol. L
LOWER CANADA, IROQUOIS, OTTAWAS: 1664-1667
Vol. LI
OTTAWAS, LOWER CANADA, IROQUOIS: 1666-1668
Vol. LII
LOWER CANADA, IROQUOIS , OTTAWAS 1667-1669
Vol. LIII
LOWER CANADA, IROQUOIS: 1669- 1670
Vol. LIV
IROQUOIS, OTTAWAS, LOWER CANADA: 1669- 1671
Vol. LV
LOWER CANADA, IROQUOIS, OTTAWAS: 1670-1672
Vol. LVI
LOWER CANADA, IROQUOIS, OTTAWAS,
HUDSON BAY: 1671 – 1672
Vol. LVII
HURONS, IROQUOIS, OTTAWAS: 1672-73
Vol. LVIII
OTTAWAS, LOWER CANADA, IROQUOIS: 1672-1674
Vol. LIX
LOWER CANADA, ILLINOIS, OTTAWAS: 1673- 1677
Vol. LX
LOWER CANADA, ILLINOIS, IROQUOIS, OTTAWAS: 1675-1677
Vol. LXI
ALL MISSIONS: 1677-1680
Vol. LXII
LOWER CANADA, IROQUOIS, OTTAWAS: 1681 – 1683
Vol. LXIII
LOWER CANADA, IROQUOIS : 1667- 1687
Vol. LXIV
OTTAWAS, LOWER CANADA, IROQUOIS, ILLINOIS: 1689-1695
Vol. LXV
LOWER CANADA, MISSISSIPPI VALLEY: 1696-1702
Vol. LXVI
ILLINOIS, LOUISIANA, IROQUOIS, LOWER CANADA: 1702- 1712
Vol. LXVI I
LOWER CANADA, ABENAKIS, LOUISIANA: 1716- 1727
Vol. LXVIII
LOWER CANADA, CREES, LOUISIANA: 1720-1736
Vol. LXIX
ALL MISSIONS: 1710-1756
Vol. LXX
ALL MISSIONS: 1747- 1764
Vol. LXXI
LOWER CANADA, ILLINOIS: 1759- 1791
Vol. LXXII
FINAL PREFACE, ADDITIONAL ERRATA
INDEX: A-I
Vol. LXXIII
INDEX: J-Z
*****************************************************
publication announcement, The Burrows Brothers Co. (1895)
*****************************************************
Francis Parkman, “The Jesuits in North America in the Seventeenth Century”; France and England in North America, Volume Two (Boston: Little, Brown, and Company, 1867)
Parkman, The Jesuits in North America, vol. 1
Parkman, The Jesuits in North America, vol. 2
*****************************************************
secondary sources
R, Vashon Rogers, “The Jesuit Relations,” Queen’s Quarterly, April 1898
Rogers, ‘The Jesuit Relations’
Charles W. Colby, “The Jesuit Relations,” The American Historical Review, October 1901
Charles W. Colby, ‘The Jesuit Relations’
William Bennett Munro, The Jesuit relations : their value as historical material (n.p., 1905).
Munro, ‘The Jesuit Relations; Their Value as Historical Material’
Joseph P. Donnelly, S.J., Thwaites’ Jesuit Relations: Errata and Addenda (Chicago: Loyola University Press, 1967)
‘Thwaites’ Jesuit Relations; Errata and Addenda’
*****************************************************
See new post on my rogers-rhetoric.com site:
— Roger W. Smith
August 2023